Reply With Quotei voted,good luck everyone,and thank you so much again for all the hard work,it was a pleasure to play them all
my top 3 1=The Turning of the Leaves 9/10/10,2=the cinder notes 9/10/9,3=Alcazar 10/9/8
We have a voting page available, so do your patriotic duty and VOTE! Big thanks to Al_B for setting this up.
Click here to vote-----> https://www.ttlg.com/polls/onemillion
FYI, I'm going to extend the voting period through the end of February, and announce the winner on March 1st.
i voted,good luck everyone,and thank you so much again for all the hard work,it was a pleasure to play them all
my top 3 1=The Turning of the Leaves 9/10/10,2=the cinder notes 9/10/9,3=Alcazar 10/9/8
I think those will be my top three, too. I'll have to review a bit before I vote, though.
And yeah. After review same top three, though in a different order.
i was going to post i figure most would have same top 3 in different orders
it comes down to voting on each categorie honestly for each persons view, of best use of space/building design/storyline
hence why they will be in different orders
it amazes me how the top 3 missions i picked were so close in different ways,one was a hands down use of best space,while another had best storyline and one had best design of map
but i do belive the top 3 i picked over all will be the same as most everyone else,just based on how voting is layed out,and yes i saw people can skip catagories on voting and just put one solid number,then and only then do i think people can pick a different mission as top 3
Voted earlier this morning. Good luck to all the authors, and thanks a lot for keeping Thief alive!
I couldnt play thief 1 missions but all the thief 2 ones.
There was one mission especially that i found so bad that i actually good sick...
I am glad that we had so many entries...
No mission was a perfect 30 however my top 3 were are all above 26 points.
Fantastic entertainment.
How are you trying to launch the Thief 1 missions? Are you launching them with Thief2, perhaps?
Hello Owl2,Originally Posted by Owl2
you can only play them if Thief Gold is installed - if this is the case, you should easily get these FM working with FMSel for TG
Greetings
It's very hard to make a real difference with such solid entries like Turning of the Leaves, Perdurance, Cinder Notes, Alcazar, and of course the genius Midsummer Night's Heist.
Just WOW!
Mostly great missions - thanks to all authors!
My faves are - in that order: Alcazar, The Cinder Notes, A Midsummer Night's Heist, The Turning of the Leaves, Recipe for Turmoil, Sabotage in Eastport, The Perdurance, Nightwalk, Sinister Night
I had a lot of (short) fun with them and will play most of them a second time to get maxloot (I normally only go for 90+% loot to enjoy the story, atmosphere & mechanics).
This contest includes so many good missions, but my top 3 would be 1. the turning of the leaves (by far) 2. the cinder notes 3. a midsummer night´s heist
Thanks to the authors for their awesome job!
Voted right now, many thanks to the authors for building such quality missions.
I’ve just voted on all entries. I don’t know if anyone else had this but because the Voting page relies on you being logged into the Forums pages, via another tab, and because the Forums page doesn’t appear to detect that you are busy on the voting page, after a time it logged me off. I’d voted for about 3 of the entries, consulting my notes and commenting but when I voted on the 4th I was told I was not logged in so the last set of comments was lost.After that I regularly clicked at random on the Forums page just to register activity.
These were all outstanding missions and I was blown away by them. Great use of the space given and great game play.
Thanks to all and good luck.
pwl
The Turning of the leaves and Cinder Notes were a step above, thanks to all who participated.
I find it rather difficult to rate the three categories on a scale from 1-10. I would have preferred a scale from 1-5.
What I did was I just multiplied an overall score of 1-10 by 3 for most missions, leading to a score like 30, 27, 24 etc. Thanks for including the option to just submit an overall rating.
I have played all 9 missions, I have 1 favorite and 4 that would take the second place
Done me voting duty. Had one favourite - and 3 very close runners up! Thanks to all authors - I had a blast playing your FMs.
I'm pretty critical, but I've genuinely enjoyed all the missions in this contest to some degree, and I think my top seven of the nine might have all been contenders to win contests 10 to 15 years ago, depending on the contest parameters.
I've settled on my top two missions and my bottom three missions, but it's a bit of a battle in between. I keep a spreadsheet where I keep tweaking the scores each time I replay a mission. I've played them all at least twice now and I still can't settle on my scores for the missions sitting at 3rd to 6th in my rankings.
I know it's silly, but I remember the slim margins of the Dark Project's 20th Anniversary Contest and so I probably give an exagerated concern to raising or lowering any mission by a single point compared to others.
Finally played them all and finished voting. I too have clear 1st and 2nd placements and bottom three placements, but the rest in the middle are very even.
I enjoyed all nine submissions. My current order from favorite to least favorite (but still enjoyable) is:spoiler:My ratings might change when I replay these. The Perdurance especially I feel I should give another shot.
- Alcazar 10/10
- A Midsummer Night's Heist 9/10
- The Cinder Notes 9/10
- The Turning of the Leaves 9/10
- Sabotage in Eastport 9/10
- Recipe for Turmoil 8/10
- A Sinister Night 7/10
- The Perdurance 6/10
- Nightwalk 5/10
I voted. Here's the list from favorite to least favorite (btw my scoring is a bit different, because atmosphere and space categories affected it a lot):
1. The Turning of the Leaves 30/30
2. Nightwalk 21/30
3. Sabotage in Eastport 27/30
4. A Midsummer Night's Heist 22/30
5. Recipe for Turmoil 24/30
6. The Perdurance 18/30
7. A Sinister Night 14/30
8. The Cinder Notes 19/30
9. Alcazar 18/30
Last edited by Galaer; 2nd Feb 2021 at 15:22.
It might be a stupid question, but I'll ask it anyways:
Will my votes count even if I don't vote for all 9 missions (obviously I won't score my own entry)?
These missions are great! I had a hard timing choosing how to rank my top 4 favourites.
Posting Permissions
